Saturday, May 10, 2008

On Empty Rice Bowl



We’ve been eating nothing else but rice even way before Merdeka. Once people used to say, if you can’t fight or perform a certain task well, it is like you didn’t eat enough rice. In
Malaysia, in-spite of all the talks about dieting, most of us eat rice at least twice a day. If you are a nasi lemak fan, maybe you would eat rice three times a day. For some folks in some states, rice is their standard breakfast. Not just nasi lemak but nasi dagang, nasi kerabu as well as various delicacies made from glutinous rice.

Malaysia is a rice country. We eat the ordinary white rice, the nasi tomato, nasi biryani, nasi minyak, nasi kandar, Hainanese chicken rice, rice porridge and the lesser known nasi rawan. For the nasi goreng, although we don’t have such things as nasi goreng Johor or nasi goreng Penang, we do have nasi goreng Thai, nasi goreng Pattaya and even nasi goreng USA.

Without doubt, rice is the centre of our existence. No Malays, nor Chinese, or Indians in Malaysia, no matter how much Mat Salleh they are trying to be, would be able to survice without eating rice for a long period of time. Even the non-rice eating immigrants of Malaya, like the Arabs finally adopted themselves in having rice as their staple food.

When the British were around, they didn’t think much about the economy of rice. You eat rice so you plant rice. There was no effort on the behalf of the colonial government to enhance either the yield per acre or the acreage itself. Even the pricing was left to the simple acts of buying and selling of the commodity. The long-term effect of supply demand of rice was never really on their agenda.

When we took over, we too didn’t pay much attention to this aspect of rice economy. We were happy with the statistics – 70 percent of which we produce our own and the rest relying on the importation from other rice producing countries. We thought it is cheaper to import rather than to be self-subsistent and we thought this trend is going to last till the end of time.

For 50 years we failed to correct this. We have forgotten that we cannot rely on others for a commodity as strategic as this. Now the Thai Government is beginning to talk about creating a rice cartel in the same way as OPEC does for oil.

If such cartel were to materialized, which I think it might just be around the corner now, the price of the importation of rice from Thailand or other rice exporting countries would be several times higher than even if we were to produce the insufficient balance on our own.

The question now is: Are we, the people, would have to pay for the differences in the price of rice, or will the Government allow further subsidies?

Given the fact that our own rice bowl is steadily depleting because the older generation of paddy planters are slowly dying and the new generation don’t really think it would be worth their effort economically to continue what their fathers had done, the future of rice certainly looks gloomy.

It is rather funny that while we are Merdeka from the British, we are never “merdeka” from relying on others to feed us with our very own staple food.

11 comments:

cakapaje said...

Salam Shirzad,

Bro, Islam has always emphasise on a nation's self-reliance especially when it comes to agriculture produce - rice, in this case.

When the Feds introduced the Masterplan for Malaysia which include the Rancangan Malaysia ke whatever number now, as well 'Buku' Hijau', the emphasis was on rubber, pineapple and some other crops which palm oil was introduced at a later stage. At one point of time, Malaysia was the world leading producer of rubber, and our pineapple was highly sought world over. Now, though we still lead in rubber technology, our yield is getting lesser and lesser.

From high yielding rubber trees, the Feds changed it to wood-based rubber tree to catch up on the world's need for furniture wood. Now that the price of rubber has risen high, our trees sadly cannot cope with the demand as its genetic design has been changed. Same thing goes with palm oil - once a need for food, the Feds are now looking at it more as alternative energy source.

Somehow, in all our techonology prowess in rubber and palm oil and some other agriculture produce, it slipped the Feds mind to invest in R&D for rice on a similar scale!

To worsen the situation, when the Feds change direction from agriculture to industry, it totally left the agriculture sector to the locust, so to speak. And now, we are beginning to see their mistakes.

The sad thing about the whole picture is that though we do have a Masterplan, it seem good only for the shelves of some ancient and antiquated library, and the Fed go on about their business of administration without a real clue as to what should be prioritised, and following the whims of the global marker and needs. What about the people's need? Food!

My apologies for a very long comment.

mOEha Aziz said...

salam shirzad,

leaping over from cakapaje's. it is never too late i guess to do something about the youngsters. yet, i wonder, our government has been telling us that they now will emphasis more on agriculture.

so many feasts and ceremonies that i'm sure had cause us afortune, still no improvement. i wonder...

p/s: i'll add u in my link.. :) wah, shah... hehehe

Sharifah Haniza said...

my daughter has got some issues with eating rice. in fact, her issues are with food. she hates them.

Kata Tak Nak said...

Is it solely because the old planters are too tired to go to the fields and the youngs are not interested?

Our youngs are not interested to do menial labour and yet we could easily overcome that by importing labour so whats the difference here with ready skilled labour available just a little up north?

I have heard of cases where very viable working papers to resuscitate the ailing padi planting sector rubbished.

The problem is that BERNAS makes too much money to its shareholders who are very powerful people. These are the people who gain if we keep on importing and they make more if the quantity is more.

Am I wrong to suspect that these same powerful people impressed on their friends, the chieftains of rice producing states, to not do much about increasing yields so that they could keep on importing. A ready excuse is available.

Now they want to form a cartel. The question is, would the government be the main player or would it be BERNAS and maybe some other private, very highly connected, players, be given the blank cheque? I suspect it is the latter.

Just my dua duit. I got here from cakapaje's and liked it already.

jaflam said...

Salam Shirzad,
There was a good article in Star today on the food production in Malaysia.

We have been blessed to have all it needs to plant anything here but unfortunately the full desires to be self sufficient in food especially rice was not there.

Even the farmers were ready if given more lands and some aids. If they ca produce 70% what is 100%.

Welcome onboard the ship but the lifeboat intact in case of emergency.

Shirzad Lifeboat said...

salam kata tak nak

I think your suspicion on Bernas is probably right. When a government agency is incorporated (from Lembaga Padi & Beras Negara, as in the case of Bernas for eg.), its primary objective to help the rakyat becomes something secondary. More often than not, such government corporation transforms itself into a competitive business entity. Shares (largely owned by the Government) are traded in the Exchange and the name of the game is about maximizing and sustaining profit at the expense of the rakyat. The civil servants entrusted as members of the Board or of the management team suddenly feel they are big time corporate leaders and successful businesmen.
The profit figures of Bernas as stated in its Annual Reports testify your suspicion. As the figures rose from ten of millions to hundreds of millions ringgit, the paddy planters of Malaysia continue to sell rice at 65 sen per kilo. No wonder they are tired to the point of giving up.

Asil said...

Cant's tell the difference, right now. Wonder why the fast food industries are getting richer?

Zawi said...

Shirzad,
When Che'gu Nazir says something is good, it must be good. I am enjoying your posting so much that I would like to add a link to it immediately. With your permission sir.

gopangkor said...

Hi, I got here via KataTakNak. The food crisis today is the outcome of greed and myopic vision of the people in power (not necessarily the Government only). Even now they are still considering short term solution, which is to import rice from neighbours. But what about long term plan? I wish to hear they announce a masterplan to resurrect rice farming in Malaysia. Or anything-la for that matter, for the survival of our children and grandchildren.

--hantutelur

tokasid said...

Salam Shirzad:

The question that needs answer is:

IS the Federal govt REALLY interested and GENUINELY commited to solve the rice problem with a long term sustainable plan?

For all this while the Feds don't have that at all.

RinG said...

well, we got a solution. there's a guy told us to eat ubi meh!!! ubi as our staple! need to staple him first lah. haha